Tesla Model S retractable door handle extended

On October 29, 2025, a 20-year-old named Samuel Tremblett crashed his 2021 Tesla Model Y into a tree in Easton, Massachusetts. The car caught fire. He survived the impact and called 911 from inside. According to the transcript included in the wrongful death lawsuit his mother later filed, he told the dispatcher he couldn’t get out, couldn’t breathe and was going to die. Firefighters spent four hours putting out the fire. His remains were found in the back seat.

Bloomberg’s investigation into Tesla door failures found at least 15 deaths in about a dozen incidents over the past decade in which occupants, or the people trying to rescue them, couldn’t open the doors of a Tesla that had crashed and caught fire. More than half of those deaths came after November 2024.

A door handle has one job. It opens the door. Not looking good. Not saving a sliver of drag. Not making the car look like it came out of a smartphone launch. Opening the door. Somewhere along the way, a big part of the industry forgot that, and the people who paid for the lesson were the ones who survived the crash and still couldn’t get out.

This isn’t only an American story, either. The regulators who have moved fastest are in Beijing, and some of the testing that measures the problem happens in Spain.

How we got here

In 2012, Tesla launched the Model S with motorized handles that slid out of the body when you approached. They became the signature of the EV revolution: sleek, futuristic, premium. Much of the industry followed in one form or another, especially on electric cars.

The sales pitch was real enough. Flush handles shave a little aerodynamic drag, and on an EV every bit of range counts. They look modern. Some can even block a door from opening into the path of a cyclist.

What got far less attention was what happens when the 12-volt battery dies, when a crash cuts power, or when a short circuit takes the system down.

That’s the core design flaw. A mechanical handle pulls a cable that moves the latch. An electronic latch needs power to open. Without power, everything depends on a mechanical emergency release existing, being reachable, and the person inside, injured and terrified, knowing where it is.

The cases

Dr. Omar Awan, Florida, 2019. A 48-year-old anesthesiologist. His Model S left the road, hit a palm tree and caught fire. A police officer arrived quickly but couldn’t open the doors because the handles were retracted flush with the body. Awan died of smoke inhalation.

Piedmont, California, November 2024. A Cybertruck hit a tree and a wall and burst into flames. Three college students died: Krysta Tsukahara, 19, Jack Nelson, 20, and Soren Dixon, 19. The coroner found that at least two died of smoke inhalation and burns rather than crash injuries. A friend in another car couldn’t open the doors and had to smash a window to pull out a fourth occupant, who survived. The Tsukahara family’s lawsuit says she survived the impact, was conscious and couldn’t get out.

Tesla Cybertruck parked

Xiaomi SU7, China, March 2025. An SU7 hit a concrete barrier on a highway in Anhui province and caught fire. Three university students died. Social media posts said the doors wouldn’t open; Xiaomi denied it, saying all four doors had mechanical emergency releases that work without power. Whatever happened in that car, the case set off the debate that led to China’s new rules.

Ford Mustang Mach-E. Ford recalled 197,432 Mach-Es from the 2021 to 2025 model years in the US over a software issue: if the 12-volt battery discharged while the car was off, the front electronic latches could stay locked when the door was shut, potentially trapping someone unable to use the interior release, like a child in a car seat. Ford’s interim advice was to carry a portable 12-volt jump starter.

Ford Mustang Mach-E, recalled over its electronic door latches

Volkswagen ID.4. VW halted ID.4 sales in the US from late 2024 into early 2025 over a handle problem: water getting into the handles could cause doors to open while the vehicle was moving. The opposite failure, from the same root: trusting a basic safety function to electronics.

In September 2025, NHTSA opened an investigation into possible door defects on certain Model Y vehicles. In December, it opened a defect petition over a Model 3 release a customer described as hidden, unlabeled and not intuitive to find in an emergency.

2021 Tesla Model Y

The crash-test paradox

For decades, crash tests measured whether you survive the hit, not whether you can get out afterward.

Your car earns five stars. The airbags fire perfectly, the crumple zones absorb the energy, the safety cell holds and the belts pretension. And then, if the battery is damaged and smoke starts filling the cabin, those beautiful, aerodynamic handles that won’t present themselves make the rest of the engineering beside the point.

Europe has started to measure it. Since 2023, Euro NCAP’s rescue and extrication protocol checks that locked doors unlock automatically after a crash, measures how much force it takes to open the side doors after two frontal tests, and, for cars with electric or retractable handles, requires them to be accessible and ready to open immediately after the test, without rescuers needing a special tool or an external power source.

What rescuers are up against

It isn’t only the people inside. Firefighters and police arriving at a crash need to get in fast, and every model hides its releases somewhere different. That’s why Euro NCAP also requires automakers to provide standardized rescue sheets, following the ISO 17840 format and limited to four pages, showing responders where the batteries, airbags, cutting points and releases are. It helps. But a rescue sheet is something a trained crew pulls up on a tablet. The officer who reaches a burning car first, or the friend in the car behind, doesn’t have it.

Time is the other enemy. A fire after a crash, especially one involving a damaged battery, can fill a cabin with smoke in very little time. In several of the cases above, the people who arrived first were seconds away from the occupants and still couldn’t get them out. In a fire, a door that takes a minute to figure out is a door that doesn’t open.

Where those tests happen

Here’s a detail from Spain, where we write from. Some of those tests are run on Spanish soil. Applus+ IDIADA’s proving ground at Santa Oliva, near Tarragona, is one of the laboratories Euro NCAP accredits to run its tests independently, including crash and post-crash assessments, according to Euro NCAP’s own list of approved labs. Cars get crashed on the Catalan coast partly to find out whether anyone can open their doors afterward.

The irony is that Europe measures the problem in its own backyard, yet its type-approval rules still don’t stop a car from being sold with handles that depend on electronics for the basic job.

"But it has a manual release!"

Flush door handle on a Tesla Model S

Yes. Cars with electronic latches have a mechanical emergency release somewhere. The problem is the "somewhere."

On some models, the rear release is hidden under a cover or at the bottom of a door pocket. On the Cybertruck, according to its own manual, the rear release is a cable under the liner of the door pocket. Front and rear releases are often different.

Now picture the moment. You’ve just crashed. You’re dazed, maybe hurt, smoke is filling the cabin, and you’re panicking. The fix is a procedure you’ve never practiced, using a hidden mechanism you didn’t know existed, in a different place front and rear, described in a manual you’ve never opened. If you’re a kid in the back, forget it.

That’s not engineering. It’s negligent optimism dressed up as minimalism. And it’s a design choice made in a studio, by people who will never be in that seat at that moment.

The fix is embarrassingly simple

None of this requires a billion-dollar breakthrough. Want a flush handle for aerodynamics? Fine. Make it mechanical: push one end, the other pivots out, pull. Electronics can add whatever they want on top, auto-presenting when you walk up, child locks, cyclist warnings, but the basic function, opening, has to be mechanical and obvious.

Some automakers already get the interior right: a light pull opens the door electronically, a hard pull opens it mechanically, because when a door won’t open in an emergency, the natural reaction is to pull harder. That’s designing for how people actually behave, not for a render. Even Tesla’s head of design has said the company is working on a redesign to make the doors more intuitive in a panic.

Where this is going

China has gone furthest. Starting January 1, 2027, every car sold there must have mechanical exterior and interior door releases, with a minimum space to get a hand in. Existing approved models have until 2029. Electric handles aren’t banned, but mechanical release becomes mandatory.

In the US, Rep. Robin Kelly introduced the SAFE Exit Act on January 6, 2026. It would require every new vehicle to have a manual release allowing timely exit regardless of any electrical failure, direct the Department of Transportation to update the federal door-latch standard, FMVSS 206, with performance and labeling requirements, and call for clearer ways for first responders to get into a cabin when electronics fail. It hasn’t passed yet, and the industry’s main trade group took no position on it at the hearing.

The era of the door that needs electricity to do the basics is ending. Not because the industry saw the light. Because people died, in cars that earned top safety ratings, after surviving the crash.

This isn’t an argument against EVs or technology. It’s an argument against the wrong priorities, the same ones behind cars that decide everything for you, which we covered in our explainer on the software-defined vehicle, and the move to screens and electronics in place of things that used to be simple, in iPads on wheels. Post-crash battery fires are their own problem, too, one we looked at in electric emergency vehicles. The cars with soul opened with a pull.

What to do today

If your car has electronic handles or latches, and plenty of modern cars do, not just EVs, find the mechanical emergency release right now. Front doors and rear doors. Practice it. Show your passengers. Show your kids, and make them try it themselves, more than once. And keep a window-breaking tool within reach of the driver’s seat. An emergency is no time to read the manual, and a car that makes you need one to escape is a car designed backwards.

Check you’re still alive.

Photos: Morten Haagensen (CC BY-SA 4.0); A1C6 (CC0); Alexander Migl (CC BY-SA 4.0); Mariordo (CC BY-SA 4.0); Morten Haagensen (CC BY-SA 4.0). Via Wikimedia Commons.

Leave a Comment